News - 5 April 2023 14:12

Rip-off or not: Jack Daniel's Vs Bad Spaniels – a case involving whiskey and a dog toy

Renowned Tennessee whiskey firm Jack Daniel's is attempting to prohibit the production and distribution of a chewy dog toy called Bad Spaniels, which is decorated in the style of one of its bottles.

The toy features a spaniel and a play on 40% alcohol by volume: "43% poo by volume, 100% smelly."

The bottle is part of the Silly Squeakers series of dog toys, which was created by VIP Products, the second-largest dog toy producer in the United States.

The idea for the Bad Spaniels spoof came to VIP's owner, Stephen Sacra, while he was out for dinner and found himself staring towards the back of a bar at the famed Jack Daniel's bottle.

A prototype design for a new toy was ready within 48 hours, and it is now the company's best-selling product in major retailers across the country.

According to the lawsuit, Bad Spaniels infringes on Jack Daniel's brand, confuses consumers, and tarnishes the company's reputation.

"Jack Daniel's loves dogs and appreciates a good joke as much as anyone. But Jack Daniel's likes its customers even more, and doesn't want them confused or associating its fine whiskey with dog poop," said the legal team.

The complaint further read that the Arizona toy maker was benefitting "from Jack Daniel's hard-earned goodwill" while also confusing consumers by persuading them to "associate Jack Daniel's whiskey with excrement".

Former Solicitor General Gregory Garre, representing the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers, debates that "giving businesses a free pass to capitalize on hard-earned trademarks ... would deeply destabilize an economic system that is rightly the envy of the world."

In response, VIP's brief said: "Freedom of speech begins with freedom to mock."

VIP's lawyer Bennett Evan Cooper said Jack Daniel's missed the point: "There is no bottle of dog food being sold. It's a pretend trademark on a pretendlabel for a pretend bottle full of pretend content. The entire thing is a parody."

A lower federal court had already decided in favor of VIP Products, which was upheld by the Nine Circuit Court of Appeals, prompting Jack Daniel's to now seek reconsideration from the Supreme Court.

The company alleges that the lower court erred in concluding that the Bad Spaniels dog toy was a "humorous" and "expressive" work, and therefore free from accusations of trademark infringement by Jack Daniel's.

If that verdict is upheld, they claim that anyone could use a famous trademark to sell sex toys, drinking games, or marijuana bongs, while deceiving customers and damaging billions of dollars in goodwill – all in the name of fun.

Cooper, VIP's lawyer, claims that Bad Spaniels toys do not deceive customers. "The source of the confusion here is not that people think that this product comes from Jack Daniel's, but the misimpression which hopefully we can clarify in this lawsuit, that you need the permission of somebody to parody them," he says.

This lawsuit involves federal trademark laws and whether and when parody is a protected expression.

At PitchMark, we discussed trademarks in a recent video that you might have missed.

PitchMark helps innovators deter idea theft, so that third parties that they share their idea with get the idea but don’t take it. Visit PitchMark.net and register for free as a PitchMark member today.

Topics

Legal affairs

Categories

Frequent rip-off of Mexican designers and why the government has stepped in to protect them

Mexico’s independent designers are facing a slew of design rip-offs by larger brands, and the indigenous designs are also not being spared. However, the Mexican government has now stepped up its efforts to protect the country’s independent and indigenous creations.
Designer Georgina Chávez is the latest victim of a rip-off. She alleged that her designs have been copied and sold on China’s onlin

Bill introduced to strip Disney of its copyright protection for Mickey Mouse may bring into question US’ global commitments to its IPR treaties

US Senator Josh Hawley has introduced the Copyright Clause Restoration Act, a new bill to strip corporations like Disney of special copyright protections. His bill would limit new copyright protections to 56 years and make the change retroactive for massive corporations like Disney that have been granted long copyright monopolies.
The action comes after Florida lawmakers deprived Disney of spec

Rip-off or not: Malaysians identify a copycat brand of Spanish frozen dessert brand ‘llaollao’ on the first day of its launch

A newly open dessert store in Malaysia is being blamed for copying the whole concept of a frozen store franchise that operates in the country.
II.Ia.Io, a Malaysian small business that specialises in frozen yogurt, recently opened its first outlet to compete with llaollao, a Spanish frozen yoghurt desert chain that operates in the nation.
As soon as the new store opened its doors to customer

5 reasons innovators should use PitchMark

Prevention is better than cure. That’s why when we buy a vehicle, we buy an insurance plan for it too. But what safeguards do innovators have when it comes to their ideas?
That’s where PitchMark comes in. Idea theft is a problem that many innovators face, and the financial loss and hurt feelings that arise from seeing your ideas copied by others without consent, credit and compensation can be

Family of Philippines’ late King of Comedy Dolphy sues Banayad Whisky for copyright infringement

The family of the Philippine’s late King of Comedy Dolphy Quizon filed a copyright infringement lawsuit against a liquor company for using his image on its products.
One of the actor's sons, Eric Quizon, warned the public against Banayad Whisky using the copyrighted image of his father in the packaging to drive sales.
Eric posted an image on Instagram of the whisky's promotional image, as we

Let your clients get the idea, without taking it.

PitchMark deters idea theft and provides you with options if it happens.

PitchMark protects the expression of your original concepts, designs, proposals, business plans, creative pitches, music - in short, any idea that you conceived and published, and claim as your own. It gives you peace-of-mind by signalling to whoever you share it with that you are its creator, and that you wish to be respected as such.

If you receive or evaluate ideas or pitches, join PitchMark as a sign of your commitment to respect the Intellectual Property rights of their creators. Attract more in-depth pitches from a wider range of sources. Highlight your PitchMark membership in your Sustainability or CSR Report.